How can we best understand historical sources?
Before diving into historical sources, we need to understand how to know if they are accurate and reliable.
To determine how accurate a source is, we can follow the “PIE” method to create a “criteria” or sorts for these sources:
| P | Provenance | Does the source have provenance—intention in creation, timeline of when it was produced, who wrote it, etc.? |
| I | Internal Evidence | Is there anything within the source itself that confirms or denies its reliability? |
| E | External Evidence | Do external historical sources confirm or challenge the document’s core claims? |
What is “Provenance”?
Below is an explanation of “provenance,” by Dr. Janet Rose.1 She explains how to understand and evaluate a document using the “five W’s”:
- Who wrote it? (What is the value of the source? E.g., personal letter from the Prime Minister to a colleague about a topic is likely to have more value than a newspaper account written by a journalist on the same topic. The assumption is that the Prime Minister has superior knowledge of the situation.)
- What is it? (A letter? Speech? Journal entry? Determine value. E.g., a politician writing a personal letter to a friend will likely be more honest than a carefully crafted speech.)
- When was it produced? (Source should be placed in context of the timeline of events. E.g., a source produced at the time of the events may be more reliable than a memoir written years later.)
- Why was it written? (What was the purpose in creation? Reveal any subjectivity or propagandist purpose. E.g., an extract from a party manifesto has a very clear political purpose.)
- Why is it important? (Know the strengths and limits of your source material. Put simply, history relies on the skilled assessment of evidence. Therefore our analysis and conclusions are likely to be flawed if we do not understand the evidence with which we are working.)
What is “Internal Evidence”?
“Internal evidence” is basically anything inside the document itself that helps you judge its authenticity, reliability, and meaning. We can ask ourselves questions like,
- Does the text remain logically consistent, or does it contradict itself?
- Does the language fit the time period it claims to come from, or does anything feel anachronistic?
- Are the details (names, dates, places, events) specific and natural, or vague and forced?
- Does the author show clear purpose or bias that shapes the way information is presented?
- Does the document reflect knowledge that the author could realistically have had?
- Is the structure coherent and well-organized, or does it feel disjointed or edited?
- Does the text read like a firsthand account or more like a secondhand reconstruction?
- Are there internal clues that help establish when, where, or why it was written?
What is “External Evidence”?
Vincent Rizzo, a university student and writer, explains how to apply the test of “external evidence” to documents using Ceasar’s Gallic Wars as an example:
“This . . . test works by determining whether historical data outside of the document in question confirms or contradicts the internal core message of the document.
“Historical data that is considered external to the document can come in the form of historical writings or physical artifacts.
“For instance, an ancient author may have quoted a passage from Caesar’s Gallic Wars into one of his works or made a reference to the occurrence of the wars. Moreover, finding physical artifacts such as weapons, military armor, or human bones in a location where a battle was said to have taken place – according to the manuscripts – would also support the ancient writings, and, therefore, bolster the reliability of the historical document.
“According to many textual scholars, Caesar’s Gallic Wars passes the external evidence test.”2
- “How to Use Provenance in History Exams,” The Tutor Team, accessed October 18, 2026, https://www.thetutorteam.com/history/how-to-use-provenance-in-history-exams/.
- Vincent Rizzo, “(Part 2) How the Bibliographical, External, and Internal Evidence Tests Work,” The Life, accessed October 18, 2026, https://thelife.com/how-the-bibliographical-external-and-internal-evidence-tests-work.


